Every premium and members-only resource for $9.99/month, as a no-commitment subscription. See the plans

PalateKit

Sign in
Menu

Request a resource

Describe the resource you are missing in one sentence. We will email you when it is published.

0 / 280

A page, a video or an image online.

Unlock PalateKit

Unlock everything

Plan

Paying means accepting our terms of sale.

Secure payment by Stripe. Receipts and invoices sent by email.

Welcome back

Sign in to install, download or save this resource. A free account is enough for free resources.

Skeptical reviewer for research papers v1.0.0

Use this resource to critically evaluate a research paper or an argument

New

  • 473 downloads
  • 71 likes
  • 74 saves

$4.99

Lifetime access to this resource, with its updates.

Install with the CLI

In a terminal, from the folder you want:

npx --yes palatekit@latest install skeptical-paper-reviewer

First time: connect the CLI with

npx --yes palatekit@latest login

The agent acts as an analytical critic. It lists contradictions, judges methodology like a skeptical peer reviewer, builds a structured brief (claims, evidence, assumptions, counterarguments), compares two approaches and imagines realistic failures. You get a clear reading and a mental model to remember.

Mostly picked by

Updated November 2, 2026

List of critical questions about a research paper.

Details

Works in
Install guides
Generates with
Your agent's model
Licence
CC0-1.0

Similar resources

View all

What you get

  • prompt.txt: eleven critical analysis requests
  • A brief method: claims, evidence, assumptions, open questions
  • Requests for analogies and a mental model

Good fit for

  • Reading a scientific paper with distance
  • Preparing a literature review
  • Stress-testing an argument

Not for

  • Getting a plain summary
  • Validating a thesis without critique
  • Replacing peer review

Tags

  • research
  • critique
  • paper
  • assumptions
  • analysis

About

You say

"Apply this skeptical reviewer to the attached paper and give me the structured brief."

List of critical questions about a research paper.

Prompt published by ersinyilmaz under the CC0-1.0 license.

Show more

Prerequisites

You bring
The paper or text to analyze and Your research question

How to use it

  1. Attach the paper or text to analyze
  2. Pick the requests that help from the list
  3. Check the flagged flaws against the sources

Content preview

Files

  • LICENSE0.6 KB
  • NOTICE-PALATEKIT.md0.4 KB
  • skeptical-paper-reviewer.md1.3 KB

Origin and licence

Modified by PalateKit

Author
ersinyilmaz
Source
github.com/f/prompts.chat/blob/cecef6fc73c2c389770695a56252d331981727de/prompts.csv
Licence
CC0-1.0

Notice

Version modifiée de « Research Weapon » (ersinyilmaz, CC0-1.0) : traduction française et fiche par PalateKit.

User reviews

–

No ratings yet

Loading reviews…

Delete your review?

Your rating and comment will be removed from the page.

Frequently asked questions

Do I need all eleven requests?

No, keep the ones that fit your reading: for example critique, assumptions and mental model.

Are the critiques reliable?

They point you to leads. Always check them in the source text.