Every premium and members-only resource for $9.99/month, as a no-commitment subscription. See the plans

PalateKit

Menu

Request a resource

Describe the resource you are missing in one sentence. We will email you when it is published.

0 / 280

Unlock PalateKit

Unlock everything

Plan

Paying means accepting our terms of sale.

Secure payment by Stripe. Receipts and invoices sent by email.

Welcome back

Sign in to install, download or save this resource. A free account is enough for free resources.

Critical persona for evaluating an idea v1.0.0

Use this resource to put an idea through a critical review before investing

New

  • 537 downloads
  • 166 likes
  • 153 saves

Free

Install with the CLI

In a terminal, from the folder you want:

npx --yes palatekit@latest install idea-critique-persona

With no option, the skill goes to ~/.agents/skills/; add --agent claude-code (or codex, cursor…) to target an agent.

First time: connect the CLI with

npx --yes palatekit@latest login

The agent takes the red-team role and looks for why the idea would fail, waste time or hit a technical or market obstacle. It runs alone or within an orchestrated debate. You get the strongest objections to address before committing.

Mostly picked by

Updated November 2, 2026

Card for the “Critical persona for evaluating an idea” skill

Details

Generates with
Your agent's model
Licence
MIT

Similar resources

View all
  • Free

    Video

    App window with zoom

    • 365365 downloads
    • 125125 likes
    • 188188 saves
    Works with
    • Claude Code
    • Codex
    • Cursor
    • and 3 more
    + HyperFrames
  • Free

    Video

    One big number

    • 463463 downloads
    • 223223 likes
    • 100100 saves
    Works with
    • Claude Code
    • Codex
    • Cursor
    • and 3 more
    + HyperFrames
  • PRO

    Video

    Three bars head to head

    • 348348 downloads
    • 133133 likes
    • 182182 saves
    Works with
    • Claude Code
    • Codex
    • Cursor
    • and 3 more
    + HyperFrames
  • PRO

    Video

    Before / after slider

    • 322322 downloads
    • 248248 likes
    • 238238 saves
    Works with
    • Claude Code
    • Codex
    • Cursor
    • and 3 more
    + HyperFrames
  • PRO

    Video

    Three-card carousel

    • 418418 downloads
    • 157157 likes
    • 101101 saves
    Works with
    • Claude Code
    • Codex
    • Cursor
    • and 3 more
    + HyperFrames
  • PRO

    Video

    Chat exchange

    • 564564 downloads
    • 127127 likes
    • 161161 saves
    Works with
    • Claude Code
    • Codex
    • Cursor
    • and 3 more
    + HyperFrames
  • PRO

    Video

    Checklist ticking off

    • 442442 downloads
    • 233233 likes
    • 160160 saves
    Works with
    • Claude Code
    • Codex
    • Cursor
    • and 3 more
    + HyperFrames

What you get

  • SKILL.md: role, core directives and behavior in the debate
  • SKILL.md: idea critique examples and best practices

Good fit for

  • You are attached to an idea and want a reality check
  • You prepare a fundraising pitch and want to anticipate objections

Not for

    Tags

    • idea
    • critique
    • risks
    • validation

    About

    You say

    “Critique this subscription app idea for gardeners: why would it fail?”

    Card for the “Critical persona for evaluating an idea” skill

    Skill published by Prince-1652 under the MIT license, delivered in its original version.

    Show more

    How to use it

    1. Install the skill in your agent's skills folder
    2. Ask your agent to put an idea through a critical review before investing
    3. Review and adjust the result

    Content preview

    Files

    • LICENSE1.1 KB
    • NOTICE-PALATEKIT.md0.5 KB
    • SKILL.md3.7 KB

    Origin and licence

    Listed unmodified

    Author
    Prince-1652
    Source
    github.com/sickn33/agentic-awesome-skills/tree/e9809578fd426a284af017c5db99f8eb6628e6ca/skills/idea-evaluator/idea-evaluator-con
    Licence
    MIT

    Notice

    « idea-evaluator-con » (Prince-1652, MIT) livré dans sa version d'origine : fiche en français et en anglais par PalateKit.

    User reviews

    –

    No ratings yet

    Loading reviews…

    Delete your review?

    Your rating and comment will be removed from the page.