Every premium and members-only resource for $9.99/month, as a no-commitment subscription. See the plans

PalateKit

Menu

Request a resource

Describe the resource you are missing in one sentence. We will email you when it is published.

0 / 280

Unlock PalateKit

Unlock everything

Plan

Paying means accepting our terms of sale.

Secure payment by Stripe. Receipts and invoices sent by email.

Welcome back

Sign in to install, download or save this resource. A free account is enough for free resources.

Pre-submission paper review v1.0.0

Use this resource to review a research paper before submitting it

New

  • 432 downloads
  • 146 likes
  • 250 saves

Free

Install with the CLI

In a terminal, from the folder you want:

npx --yes palatekit@latest install pre-submission-paper-review

With no option, the skill goes to ~/.agents/skills/; add --agent claude-code (or codex, cursor…) to target an agent.

First time: connect the CLI with

npx --yes palatekit@latest login

The agent first judges the research paradigm and venue fit, then reviews the paper on five dimensions: macro logic, writing details, English grammar, LaTeX formatting and figure quality. It quotes each affected passage, ranks findings as critical, major or minor, and suggests a fix. You get a report with a score and a submission recommendation.

Mostly picked by

Updated November 2, 2026

Table of review findings ranked critical, major and minor.

Details

Generates with
Your agent's model
Licence
CC-BY-4.0

Similar resources

View all
  • Free

    Skills

    Knowledge wiki setup

    • 418418 downloads
    • 129129 likes
    • 161161 saves
    Works with
    • Claude Code
    • Codex
    • Cursor
    • and 3 more
  • Free

    Skills

    Wiki health check

    • 552552 downloads
    • 202202 likes
    • 127127 saves
    Works with
    • Claude Code
    • Codex
    • Cursor
    • and 3 more
  • Free

    Skills

    Ask your wiki

    • 374374 downloads
    • 131131 likes
    • 214214 saves
    Works with
    • Claude Code
    • Codex
    • Cursor
    • and 3 more
  • Free

    Skills

    Wiki source ingestion

    • 315315 downloads
    • 230230 likes
    • 246246 saves
    Works with
    • Claude Code
    • Codex
    • Cursor
    • and 3 more
  • Free

    Skills

    Wiki auditor agent

    • 556556 downloads
    • 205205 likes
    • 192192 saves
    Works with
    • Claude Code
    • Codex
    • Cursor
    • and 3 more
  • Free

    Skills

    UX research assistant

    • 598598 downloads
    • 142142 likes
    • 236236 saves
    Works with
    • Claude Code
    • Codex
    • Cursor
    • and 3 more
  • Free

    Skills

    Wiki ingestion agent

    • 437437 downloads
    • 162162 likes
    • 191191 saves
    Works with
    • Claude Code
    • Codex
    • Cursor
    • and 3 more
  • Free

    Skills

    Wiki librarian agent

    • 304304 downloads
    • 120120 likes
    • 217217 saves
    Works with
    • Claude Code
    • Codex
    • Cursor
    • and 3 more

What you get

  • SKILL.md: review procedure, severity taxonomy, integrity gate, report format
  • Guide to paper logic and structure
  • Grammar, LaTeX and figure rules, plus a list of phrasings to avoid
  • Section-by-section writing guides

Good fit for

  • You are submitting a paper within days
  • You want to spot the flaws a reviewer would flag first
  • You write in English as a non-native speaker

Not for

  • Structuring a paper that is not written yet
  • Replacing feedback from co-authors or a domain specialist

Tags

  • paper
  • review
  • research
  • latex
  • submission

About

You say

"Review this draft before next week's conference submission and rank the problems by severity."

Table of review findings ranked critical, major and minor.

Skill published by HKUST-DIAL under the CC-BY-4.0 license.

Show more

Prerequisites

You bring
The paper text (full or key sections) and The target journal or conference

How to use it

  1. Install the skill and provide the paper text and the target venue.
  2. State the research paradigm if the agent asks.
  3. Fix critical findings first, then major ones, and run the review again.

Content preview

Files

  • LICENSE1 KB
  • NOTICE-PALATEKIT.md0.4 KB
  • references/forbidden-patterns.md4.8 KB
  • references/grammar-rules.md4.8 KB
  • references/latex-rules.md4.5 KB
  • references/logic-and-structure.md4.7 KB
  • references/section-guides.md5.4 KB
  • SKILL.md12.7 KB

Origin and licence

Modified by PalateKit

Author
hkustdial
Source
github.com/hkustdial/supervisor-skills/tree/a20d76ef3979b804d7dbf599d577826957e0a8a9/skills/pre-submission-reviewer
Licence
CC-BY-4.0

Notice

Version modifiée de « pre-submission-reviewer » (hkustdial, CC-BY-4.0) : traduction française et fiche par PalateKit.

User reviews

–

No ratings yet

Loading reviews…

Delete your review?

Your rating and comment will be removed from the page.

Frequently asked questions

Does the skill rewrite the paper?

No. It produces a list of findings and fix suggestions. You decide what to change.

It names other skills. Are they required?

No. They only help draft a paper before review. The review works on its own.